Returning to work after alcohol treatment in Canada: return-to-work agreements and testing
Returning to work after alcohol treatment in Canada: the duty to accommodate, what return-to-work and last chance agreements cover, and how testing works.
Published on
Going back to work after treatment for alcohol is a big step. There's the job itself, the questions from coworkers, and often an agreement with the employer about testing and follow-up. Knowing your rights and what these agreements usually contain makes the return less stressful for everyone, and gives you the best chance of keeping both your job and your recovery on track.
This article is general information, not legal advice. The rules differ between federally and provincially regulated workplaces, between provinces, and in unionized workplaces, where the collective agreement matters. Talk to your union representative or an employment lawyer before you sign an agreement.
Alcohol dependence is a disability under human rights law
The Canadian Human Rights Act defines disability to include previous or existing dependence on alcohol or a drug, and provincial human rights laws protect it as well. In Ontario, for example, the Human Rights Commission's policy states that addictions to alcohol or drugs are disabilities under the Human Rights Code. That means:
The employer has a duty to accommodate, up to the point of undue hardship. Accommodation can include time off for treatment, a gradual return, modified or different duties, and time for appointments and aftercare.
The employee has a part to play. That usually means taking part in the process, following the treatment plan, and giving the information needed to plan the return, such as fitness to work and any restrictions. It generally doesn't mean handing over your full medical file.
Relapse can be part of dependence. The Canadian Human Rights Commission's guide on accommodating substance dependence notes that relapse is often part of the condition, so plans may need to be adjusted rather than ended.
Why coming forward early matters
Many workplace policies treat a request for help very differently from a positive test after an incident. In Stewart v. Elk Valley Coal (2017), the Supreme Court of Canada upheld the firing of a mine worker who didn't disclose a drug dependence until after a workplace accident, under a policy that offered treatment to employees who came forward first. Read your employer's policy, and consider using your employee assistance program (EAP) early.
What a return-to-work agreement usually covers
Confirmation from your treating professional that you're fit to return, and any restrictions
Continuing care, such as counselling, peer support, medication or appointments
What's expected about alcohol at work, and sometimes outside work for safety-sensitive jobs
Testing: how, how often, who sees the results and for how long
What happens after a positive or missed test
Who sees what information, and how it's kept confidential
Review dates and an end date
Last chance agreements are stricter. They're usually offered when an employee has already been disciplined, and breaking them can lead to dismissal. Arbitrators have upheld dismissals for breaching them. Still, the Ontario Human Rights Commission's policy says such an agreement doesn't remove the employer's duty to accommodate if a relapse happens. Read every term carefully, and get advice before you sign.
Testing at work: what the law allows
Testing that's part of an individual return-to-work plan is different from testing every employee.
Random breath tests in non-unionized workplaces. In Entrop v. Imperial Oil (2000), the Ontario Court of Appeal found that random alcohol breath testing of employees in safety-sensitive jobs could be justified, because a breath test measures current impairment, as long as the consequences of a positive test are tailored to the person. Random urine drug tests couldn't be justified the same way, because they show past use rather than impairment.
Random tests in unionized workplaces. In Irving Pulp & Paper (2013), the Supreme Court of Canada upheld an arbitration decision striking down random breath testing that a paper mill had imposed on its own. A dangerous workplace alone wasn't enough without evidence of a wider problem, such as a general problem with alcohol use in the workplace.
Testing after treatment. The Ontario Human Rights Commission's policy recognizes that testing can be part of a return-to-work or last chance agreement after treatment.
In short, testing tied to one person's agreed return-to-work plan is common, while random testing of everyone is much harder to justify.
Why remote breath tests fit a return-to-work plan
Tests can happen anywhere. Before a shift, on days off or in the evening, not only at the worksite, which matters if your agreement covers more than working hours.
Each test is verified. Video and location show who took the test and where, with the exact BAC.
More privacy. You don't have to be tested in front of coworkers, and results can go to occupational health or the EAP rather than a direct supervisor.
Your own record. You keep a dated record of every test, which helps if there's ever a disagreement about what happened.
Tips for employees
Get the agreement in writing, keep a copy, and ask about anything you don't understand.
Ask exactly who will see your results and what else they'll be told.
Plan for practical problems, such as a dead phone or a shift change, and tell the right person right away if a test is missed.
Keep your own copies of reports.
Involve your union representative if you have one.
Tips for employers
Assess each employee individually instead of applying one rule to everyone.
Involve occupational health or the EAP, and limit who sees test results.
Decide in advance how you'll respond to a positive or missed test, and apply it consistently.
Document the accommodation steps you take.
Get legal advice before introducing a testing policy or a last chance agreement.
How Druchol works for return-to-work testing
An employer, occupational health provider or EAP can be added as a monitor or viewer on the employee's account, or use a company account to manage several employees and pay for them. Tests can be fixed (for example before each shift), random (up to 4 a day) or sent on demand. The employee gets a text and an email about an hour before each scheduled test, and every test is recorded on video with its location and exact BAC. A test not done within an hour of its due time is recorded as missed, contacts can turn on emails for passed, failed or missed tests in their profile, and monthly PDF reports include a QR code to verify them. It's $79 CAD a month plus a $150 CAD breathalyzer, plus applicable taxes. See how Druchol works for pre and post employment testing.
Alcohol dependence is protected as a disability under Canadian human rights law, so an employer must accommodate it up to the point of undue hardship. An employer can still enforce safety rules, workplace policies and performance standards. If you're facing discipline, talk to your union representative or an employment lawyer.
Do I have to tell my employer about my treatment?
You usually need to give enough information to plan your return, such as whether you're fit to work and any restrictions, not your full medical file. Check your workplace policy, since some treat employees who ask for help before an incident very differently from those who don't.
Can my employer require alcohol testing when I go back?
Testing is often part of a return-to-work or last chance agreement after treatment, especially in safety-sensitive jobs. Random testing of all employees is much harder to justify under Canadian law.
How long does return-to-work testing last?
It's set in your agreement. Ask for review dates and an end date in writing, and for testing to step down as your record grows.
What is a last chance agreement?
It's a written agreement that gives an employee a final chance to keep their job, usually with conditions such as treatment, abstinence and testing. Breaking it can lead to dismissal, so get advice before you sign.
What happens if I relapse during a return-to-work agreement?
It depends on the agreement. Under a last chance agreement it can lead to discipline or dismissal, but human rights law may still require the employer to consider accommodation. Tell your contact person right away, and talk to your union representative or a lawyer.